According to a new study, for all marketing’s obsession with return on investment, it’s not being used to set budgets.
A survey of 243 CMOs and other marketing executives found that 57% don’t establish their budgets according to ROI measures. Sixty-eight percent of respondents said they base their budget decisions on historical spending levels, while 28% said they go with gut instinct. And 7% said most of or all their spending decisions aren’t based on any metrics at all.
The study was conducted in January and February by the Columbia Business School Center on Global Brand Leadership and the New York American Marketing Association, and results were presented at the Brands Innovation Technology conference in New York on March 5.
The state of the art remains surprisingly primitive, according to the survey, in which half of respondents didn’t include any financial outcome when defining marketing ROI, and 22% use the most basic measure — brand awareness — to gauge marketing ROI without necessarily determining even whether the awareness is positive.
As one respondent colorfully put it, his company’s marketing ROI measurement is like “pissing in the wind.”
Maybe the marketers shouldn’t be blamed. A presentation at the Marketing Accountability Standards Board summit last month in St. Petersburg, Fla., showed how questionable even widely cited marketing-effectiveness measures can be.
MASB President Meg Blair noted that four major brand-valuation firms (Interbrand, Millward Brown’s BrandZ, CoreBrand and Brand Finance) peg General Electric’s brand value at between $30.5 billion to $50.3 billion. Two of those firms had GE’s brand value rising in the past year: one by 2%, one by 12%. Two showed its valuation falling: one by 4%, one by 10%.
To address the discrepancies and move toward marketing-effectiveness measures that might gain broad acceptance, MASB is preparing to launch a Brand Investment and Valuation Pilot study as soon as next month. The intent of the study, to be concluded by 2014, is to develop a widely accepted methodology that marketers can use to value their brands and guide their investment decisions. It will include an analysis of a Kimberly-Clark Corp. brand, among others, Ms. Blair said.
The post Study Finds Marketers Don’t Practice ROI They Preach appeared first on Allocadia.